Would You Rather Give £110,000 To Your Family, Or To Gordon Brown On Your Death?The idea of giving away huge chunks of your estate to save inheritance tax at first sight sounds attractive, until you realise that the money is gone for good, regardless of the needs of your surviving spouse.
In practice, therefore husbands and wives will often wish to leave the whole of their estate to their surviving spouse under the terms of their Will since the comfort and security of the spouse is paramount. Transfers between UK domiciled spouses are wholly exempt from Inheritance Tax and therefore there is no tax to pay on the first death.
Purely from an Inheritance Tax point of view, however, no advantage will have been taken of the fact that on the first death one can leave the nil rate band, currently £275,000, by Will to the children or other beneficiaries at 0% Inheritance Tax, and on the survivor's death another nil rate band will be available. This is a saving of Inheritance Tax of £110,000.
The problem with leaving this sum directly to the children is that it may not leave the surviving spouse with sufficient funds to maintain a comfortable standard of living, particularly where the estates are relatively modest. There is also the danger of children becoming insolvent or losing the inheritance in a divorce settlement, or not being “responsible” enough to handle receipt of funds directly.
The answer is for husband and wife to set up
Nil Rate Band Discretionary Trusts in their Wills. The notes which follow assume that it is the husband who dies first.
On the death of the first spouse £275,000 from his estate, or the balance of the nil band then available (taking account of any lifetime gifts within the previous 7 years) is placed into a Discretionary Trust created by his Will.
The Trustees of the Nil Rate Band Discretionary Will Trust have complete discretion as to how and when the Trust funds are distributed. For this reason it is important that the surviving spouse be protected by appointing her as one of the Trustees with one or two friendly co-Trustees. (However, the Trustees should not be exactly the same group of persons as the Executors of the will.)
The Trustees of a Discretionary Trust have complete discretion as to how and when they distribute Trust funds. Trust funds can be used for the surviving spouse's benefit and any income may be paid to her to ensure that her comfort and security are not prejudiced. However, on the subsequent death of the surviving spouse, her estate should not include the amount in the Trust fund and so at current rates of tax the IHT saving on her death will be £110,000 (£275,000 x 40%). Any growth in the initial fund of £275,000 will also have escaped IHT on her death.
Where possible, it is advisable that the Nil Rate Band Discretionary Trust should be funded by cash and/or investments other than an interest in the family home. There is then no harm in the surviving spouse being one of the potential beneficiaries. The Trustees can resolve each year, it appropriate, to appoint the income to the surviving spouse (possibly not all the income every year or the Trust may be attacked as a sham) and if the income is insufficient they may also advance capital or lend capital to the surviving spouse.
Where the nil rate band amount can only be funded using a share of the family home, additional pre death arrangements are required.
It is usual for the family home to be owned by both spouses as "joint tenants". On the death of the first spouse, ownership of the whole automatically passes to the survivor and thus no part of the value of the home is available to fund the Nil Rate Band Will Trust. If the joint tenancy is severed so that the spouses own the property as "tenants in common", each spouse can leave his or her share under the terms of the Will. If no other assets, such as cash or investments, are available to fund the Nil Rate Band Trust, it would be possible for the Trustees to take a “charge” over the share of the property owned by the testator to satisfy the legacy to the Nil Rate Band Trust. This gives the surviving spouse the security of control over the home, but still enables the Nil Rate Band to be utilised on the first death. This is, however, a complex area and extreme care needs to be taken in drafting the Will and administering the Estate.
Should you have any queries regarding this article please contact Carolyn Spencer, Tax Manager on
Carolyn@nunn-hayward.com or 01753 888211.